Just One Oscar

Jokingly argued for Best Sound, but ultimately conceded to Will Ferrell after debating whether John C. Reilly deserved it over Mark Wahlberg's actual nomination for The Departed

‘Aliens’Bill Simmons

Best Director for James Cameron ('Big Jim'), calling it astonishing action filmmaking

‘Apollo 13’Amanda Dobbins

Hanks over the movie (her 'hot take'), but would be happy with the movie winning

‘Apollo 13’Bill Simmons

Best Picture, with Hanks as a close alternative

Episode	Host	Answer
‘It Follows’	Bill Simmons	Cinematography
‘It Follows’	Chris Ryan	Mitchell (presumably director Mitchell) for Direction
‘It Follows’	Joanna Robinson	Disasterpeace for Score
‘Friday the 13th’	Bill Simmons	The Score — The score
‘Friday the 13th’	Chris Ryan	Tom Savini, the makeup and special effects guy
‘Law Abiding Citizen’	Bill Simmons	Gerard Butler for Best Actor
‘Rambo: First Blood Part II’	Bill Simmons	Frank Stallone for 'Peace in Our Life' (song), suggests it goes to special effects since that's what typically gets nominated
‘Talladega Nights’	Craig Horlbeck	Will Ferrell
‘Talladega Nights’	Danny Heifetz	Jokingly argued for Best Sound, but ultimately conceded to Will Ferrell after debating whether John C. Reilly deserved it over Mark Wahlberg's actual nomination for The Departed
‘Aliens’	Bill Simmons	Best Director for James Cameron ('Big Jim'), calling it astonishing action filmmaking
‘Apollo 13’	Amanda Dobbins	Hanks over the movie (her 'hot take'), but would be happy with the movie winning
‘Apollo 13’	Bill Simmons	Best Picture, with Hanks as a close alternative